Remember The Dress? That infuriating meme that made everyone fight about the colour of a dress? Well, there’s a new version of that and it’s simply called #TheShoe.

WHICH COLOR MATCHES THE SHOES THE BEST pic.twitter.com/Qv3mpOOf8w

— a (@totallymendes) July 8, 2015

Now, the shoe is a little different. It’s different, because while the blue and gold from The Dress debate are like totally different hues, the two purples in the photo are definitely from the same family.

So, which is it: a light purple, or a vibrant fuchsia? At first glance, it’s easy to see one over the other. In the light, you think, oh that’s totally a fuchsia shoe. But when you start to look over it again and again, your eye begins to focus on shadows, where the shoe is darker, more muted.

And then you realize that this isn’t a debate at all. The nail polish colour that matches these shoes the most is both of them. Because the shoe is in fact both colours. See?

The Dress it is not, which is great because who needs to cry over something like that again. But what do you think? What colour are you seeing? Tell us in the comments!